Hearts of Iron IV

Hearts of Iron IV

Adiya's Historical Flag Pack
Adiya  [개발자] 2016년 6월 12일 오전 10시 59분
Non-historical Flag Request and Discussion
There are plenty of flags that is hard to be determined, mostly are those in communist and fascist ideology. There should be some historical or good fictional design out there. If you want a particular flag in the mod, please make a request with references.

The factors that I will accept a request: (priority in order)
  1. The flag excisted historically (e,g, from a historical regime)
  2. The flag of a historical major party in this ideology
  3. Fictional flag with legitate design
  4. Looks good

There are 4 different flags of different ideologies for each nation:
- communism
- democracy
- fascism
- neutrality

here is a preview image of all VANILLA flags for reference
http://i.imgur.com/bZl2SOi.png

you can also find preview image of my mod (maybe not up to date)
http://images.akamai.steamusercontent.com/ugc/269468379398607010/64E683701851716897058697FB530F65862BB46F/



Here is something I wrote about those non-historical flags
Since most of those parties were never reached the government, it's hard to assume what the national flag under their regime is gonna be.

IMO purely using the party flag is not a good solution anyway.

From the real history, most communist regime have a revolutionary new flag design; most fascist regime had more conservative design, maybe because most of them were rised during the war and doesn't really got time to think about it.

The German Third Reich seems to be the only one who completely adopted party flag (with only slight off-centre adjustment) as the national flag. Even though there were a transition when during 1933 and 1935, the old empire flag (back, white and red tricolor) was used in conjunction with the party flag (swastika).

Back to the topic, it's really impossible to "predict" what's the national flag will be when those communist/fascist parties never build a regime to rule the country; or even they had ever climbed to the top, but didn't last long during the war time.

Through the histroy, my guess is if the fascist regime built on long traditional monarchy government, the national flag wouldn't change much (Italy, Japan, Hungary etc.). That's why I believe most european countries including scandinavian countries are in this case.

The Germany was however at the time no longer a monarchy nation (Weimar Republic), that's why they didn't treasure tradition that much. It was like the red revolution of communism, breaking everything old and build things completely new. (It's only my perspective)

With all these being said, since there are no actual historical being of those national flags under communist/fascist regime, there shouldn't be "correct" or "incorrect". The possiblity was really opened, there should be only "plausible" or "implausible".

Luckily there are some wounderful designs under alternative history either looks legimate or purely cool. I think most of the design was under some serious consideration combining historical evidence and the cultural legancies. It's always debatable why using this instead of that. What I do was trying finding a delightful design, or stick with vanillas. To be honest I myself don't care that much about fictional flags of minor nations. For the majoy nation, I would like to pay more attetion to find to best suitable design, even design it myself when necessary. (With last update, I made some scandinavian communist flags on my own)
Adiya 님이 마지막으로 수정; 2016년 6월 15일 오후 11시 44분
< >
23개 댓글 중 1-15개 표시
Will 2016년 6월 12일 오후 2시 46분 
Emerald-Rose 2016년 6월 12일 오후 5시 59분 
OG Commie Cat님이 먼저 게시:
you should put this https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/95/Flag_of_Spain_(1931_-_1939).svg/2000px-Flag_of_Spain_(1931_-_1939).svg.png
instead of the old flag with just the star in the middle


That's the democracy/neutral flag already iirc.
Emerald-Rose 2016년 6월 12일 오후 6시 04분 
If you could, it'd be nice for you to link to an imgur gallery of the original ingame flags and your edits so we have everything in one, comprehensive place and know what needs editing.
Adiya  [개발자] 2016년 6월 12일 오후 8시 09분 
linkeagleandzen님이 먼저 게시:
If you could, it'd be nice for you to link to an imgur gallery of the original ingame flags and your edits so we have everything in one, comprehensive place and know what needs editing.
done
Old School Internet Warlord 2016년 6월 13일 오전 5시 11분 
Maybe for fascist USA the flag from "Man in the High Castle". Simply because it looks pretty cool.
Adiya  [개발자] 2016년 6월 13일 오전 5시 52분 
Old School Internet Warlord님이 먼저 게시:
Maybe for fascist USA the flag from "Man in the High Castle". Simply because it looks pretty cool.
It's not convincing enough, since in the TV show the USA was german occupied. But yea, it's a cool design
Old School Internet Warlord 2016년 6월 13일 오전 9시 00분 
Sure. Like I said it just looks cool.
Heitri 2016년 6월 15일 오전 5시 39분 
It would be a good idea to use the actual Rex's flag for fascist Belgium instead of the current one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rexist_Party#/media/File:Drapeau_de_Rex.svg

If you want more graphical details, the former leader of Rex shows an original flag here : https://youtu.be/sNxxKUsdVbY?t=1h29m

It's a number 2.
Adiya  [개발자] 2016년 6월 15일 오후 11시 49분 
Heitri님이 먼저 게시:
It would be a good idea to use the actual Rex's flag for fascist Belgium instead of the current one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rexist_Party#/media/File:Drapeau_de_Rex.svg

If you want more graphical details, the former leader of Rex shows an original flag here : https://youtu.be/sNxxKUsdVbY?t=1h29m

It's a number 2.
I have some similar request these days regarding using the fascist party flag to be the national flag. So I wrote some thought and posted in the thread, you can check it out.
abloobloo 2016년 6월 17일 오전 11시 37분 
So here's the National Unity Party flag I was talking about for Canada : https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/ac/Flag_of_the_Parti_National_Socialiste_Chretien.svg/150px-Flag_of_the_Parti_National_Socialiste_Chretien.svg.png

Leader Adrien Arcand in his party uniform (note the red on white swastika and blue uniform; in Canada party members were called "blue shirts") : http://media1.ledevoir.com/images_galerie/d_49008_61069/adrien-arcand.jpg

Wikipedia page on Adrien Arcand, the "Canadian führer" : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adrien_Arcand

The NUP party flag is probably not the absolute ideal flag but it is ten miles ahead of the anachronistic abortion currently in the game considering the maple leaf flag wasn't even a thing until 1965.
Adiya  [개발자] 2016년 6월 17일 오후 6시 11분 
pocket toaster님이 먼저 게시:
So here's the National Unity Party flag I was talking about for Canada : https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/ac/Flag_of_the_Parti_National_Socialiste_Chretien.svg/150px-Flag_of_the_Parti_National_Socialiste_Chretien.svg.png

Leader Adrien Arcand in his party uniform (note the red on white swastika and blue uniform; in Canada party members were called "blue shirts") : http://media1.ledevoir.com/images_galerie/d_49008_61069/adrien-arcand.jpg

Wikipedia page on Adrien Arcand, the "Canadian führer" : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adrien_Arcand

The NUP party flag is probably not the absolute ideal flag but it is ten miles ahead of the anachronistic abortion currently in the game considering the maple leaf flag wasn't even a thing until 1965.
Was the NUP the only fascist party in Canada at the time?
abloobloo 2016년 6월 17일 오후 10시 31분 
The NUP itself came into existence as a fusion of various fascist and national socialist movements. There were a few independent ones, but they were much smaller. The NUP was by far the most popular fascist party before they were banned.
Tuskin 2016년 6월 18일 오후 7시 44분 
pocket toaster님이 먼저 게시:

The NUP party flag is probably not the absolute ideal flag but it is ten miles ahead of the anachronistic abortion currently in the game considering the maple leaf flag wasn't even a thing until 1965.

Not entirely true, that symbol is the army symbol, not the stylized maple leaf seen on our current flag. Our military did use the Maple leaf in WW2.

Either way it is a military flag, not a Fascist flag, so it doesn't make sense here.
Tuskin 님이 마지막으로 수정; 2016년 6월 18일 오후 7시 45분
Adiya  [개발자] 2016년 6월 20일 오전 12시 57분 
Tuskin님이 먼저 게시:
pocket toaster님이 먼저 게시:

The NUP party flag is probably not the absolute ideal flag but it is ten miles ahead of the anachronistic abortion currently in the game considering the maple leaf flag wasn't even a thing until 1965.

Not entirely true, that symbol is the army symbol, not the stylized maple leaf seen on our current flag. Our military did use the Maple leaf in WW2.

Either way it is a military flag, not a Fascist flag, so it doesn't make sense here.
Yea, it's kinda explained where vanilla design comes from.

The reason I'm not pro NUP's flag is that it's almost identical to NSDAP, very unlikely to be adopted as a national flag of Canada.
-sb- zveroboy 2016년 6월 20일 오전 5시 55분 
This guy has some interesting ideas btw: http://steamproxy.net/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=707274173

I especially like the Arrow Cross Party-style flag for fascist Hungary, and the South African fascist flag. Not sure where it's from (could be made up) but it looks great. Very German.

The Turkish communist design is great, too.

Don't be afraid to steal good ideas, Adiya xD
< >
23개 댓글 중 1-15개 표시
페이지당 표시 개수: 1530 50