Bopin_Robin tarafından yazılan son incelemeler

I have 50 hours on this game in the span of 2 weeks
I ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ love this game

I have 200 hours on PS4.

almost Everything about this game I love



Gunplay the AI adapting to your strats it's all awesome, But the enemies still stay the same mostly, they just learn your strats and reverse engineer them sometimes

go through night, flashlights and nightvison

non-lethal? they will bring helmets and body armor.

chemical warfare? gas masks

use any weapon too much? RIot armor

It's like alien isolation with the AI adapting.

you have to adapt as much as them while also trying to recruit some of them into your motherbase.


The gameplay is amazing although the first part is a little slow the camera work is amazing and after that every mission is very open to choice. Like the mission where you have to rescue a cybernetics Specialist. You can easily extract him if you take out the guards. you can take out the power to get them distracted. then you can stealthfully go in and take them out. or you can get a car, put C-4 on it then throw it into the enemies. while they're busy with that you pull out your sniper and knock them out. when you finally meet the prisoner, you have to extract him through the dozen enemies that you pissed off? no, if you look closely you can see a hole in the roof, extract him through there. then call in a airstrike to kill the people waiting for you.


the story, the title says it all, it's a rise and fall but without an end. you feel "phantom pain" when you're done with it. it's genious bravo vi- I mean Kojima. what makes it so good is that all the characters feel real, except for one but you'll understand it when you play it. I'm not going to spoil too much but it makes you feel "invisible". every piece of detail, music, dialogue means something

For instance, the songs "Here's to You" and "The Man Who Sold the World" both serve as hints, deepening the story's meaning. These music choices, along with other elements, resonate emotionally with the player, heightening the sense of loss and reflection.
small Spoilers for this paragraph skip it if you plan on playing blind
you find out one character is alive in the medical ward, as you do the missions your soldiers start mentioning that you're randomly walking to construction area in the middle of the night often, you don't understand it at first (this was my second playthrough of side quest and my first time hearing this conversation from the soldiers) but when you finish it you will understand it.


there is a lot of references to real life media that actually change your understanding to the story as a whole the reason there's so many references to other old media is probably that Venom snake is hallucinating but thats just a theory A GAME THEORY.
for references it's
-moby ♥♥♥♥
-1984
-diamond dogs (from david bowie)
-lord of the flies
-frankenstein
While some of these references may seem obscure, they provide crucial insights into the game's themes and characters.

One small problem about the game, The main character Venom snake doesn't talk often during the main missions, although I get why, I just want more lines. the cut lines are actually pretty good. and i wish we got more. I feel they focused more on snake as a unreliable narrator because he cant tell reality time to time and you have to piece together clues to figure it out since he has a piece of ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ shrapnel in his head

base building is awesome. You have to actively grow the base while developing new guns and ways of making money.

The weapon mechanics are incredibly satisfying. For instance, the durability of silencers requires you to think carefully about your choices during combat. Should you take the risk of firing too much, knowing that your silencer could wear out? These details add depth to the gameplay, making every decision feel impactful. unless you get the rocket arm or the stun arm, but even then they're not that useful or have a cooldown.

go play the game
my confusing review is not enough to say how good this game is. the game has an experience that is both rich and engaging.

Also M(edic)iller hamburger story, chef's kiss
but also ♥♥♥♥ konami

♥♥♥♥ RED DEAD 2 GAMBLING FOR LIFE!

THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW THE HAND MUST GROW

reasons not to play this game and also I've replayed the game 3 times in a row, 280+ hours on ps4,

I've been trying to say this for a long time, It's been 4 years since I started playing the game

Cons:

it's Rockstar, so they will spend more on the details on useless things like horse balls instead of said details for the weapons and mechanics to make them feeling more in depth. like for a game that's a shooter, why do you have to click twice to shot it and wait 1 second in between, and with the ♥♥♥♥♥♥ feeling with games

they forgot about 80% of the cast and lore for all the other side characters inside the game, like for Lenny ,Molly,BIll,Javier,Sean,Kieran,miss Grimshaw, Mary beth,the Pinkertons,Uncle,

95% of the missions is following someone while also being very restricting when it isn't while also 2 of the chapters are filler,

the community will send you death threats over calling the game overrated, they will also get angry when you don't like the game and say "you want this game to be like fortnite!!!!" and live in an echo chamber
they are the reason the game was an 8/10 to 6/10 (not because of the social media sites, but the online game which has been left 4 dead 2 'you see what i did there?')
they cheat, and then act like RDR2 is their entire life. they also have some sort of dementia because they all make the same posts.

every mechanic inside the game has already been done better with their older counterparts
being able to greet and antagonise you can already do that in bully. more in depth gameplay and choices, GTA 4, the story (half and half feeling for me) GTA 4 yet again, controls, gta San Andreas (mostly the game still kinda feels off when playing). if you want a game that really changes as you play, go play Deus Ex, if you want more in depth characters go play the MGS games. Play fallout for the honor system if you enjoyed it in RDR2. if you want more everything, even in details play Half-Life 2

Honor system means almost nothing gameplay wise, It changes a bit for the story but that's it you get cool cosmetics I guess. dialogue changes but you get nothing for being bad. I get that it's "realistic" I guess, but like why, it's a game not real life.
Let's compare this to a game that also has an honor system and is more story based, infamous second son, there's two choices in the game, where you are either bad or good, depending on these choices the game changes a lot, but not to the point where it's completely different, your outfit’s color changes to red and you become pale or to white and your character is liberating people. Some abilities are locked and some are open. While in rdr2 nothing changes even in the ending you got the short end of the stick, it just feels like Bioshock where it's not even worth being bad. Arthur just treats himself worst


people say that since it's the 1800s there's no guns or weapons you can use yes there is, if you go further back in history there’s Crossbows, war picks, hand cannons, sling shots, powdered weapons like the blunderbuss, In Saint Denis there are many people there from different cultures, it would be very awesome to get their weapons, like katanas and rapiers. “But then it’s not a cowboy game” they have a bow they have a pirate sword. the guns feels all very similar to the point where it's not fun to use them, the bow is cool, then you have a repeater that shoots out BB darts but sounds really really cool.
then you have the shotguns which are probably the best parts of the game, they have cool finishers and are a lot more unique. Then there's dead eyes that make the game way too easy. but without it the game makes me feel like I've been guilded. The melee combat is really good though.

Every part of the game babysits you with following missions or with slow animations. I think that's why when you see popular youtubers playing the game you see them in the open, like bed bananas. Look It’s alright to have a game where it’s restricting and story based, but you give us so many ways of dealing with problems

the protagonist is praised for being good to the point where the other main character is forgotten. although I'd like to say he deserves to be the best character in gaming, there are many more ones that are like him but forgotten (if yall want you can skip this since paragraph either way I agree that hes a good character just over loved)
Lincoln clay, A man who cares for his family but when he's losing it he shows who he truly is, they both bottle up their feelings and no one else understands them. they are both stoic. they both try to justify murdering thousands, all for the sake of their family. they both are traumatized by what they didn't do. in the end they try to redeem themselves for what they have but fail (well except for one ending for both of them). I know its not really an fair comparison since Clay doesn't show his feelings often only at the end and start of the game.
rockstar made many better characters that I feel represent regret and health issues better, Niko Belic and Trevor Phillips. Niko bottles his emotions up for most of the games and only reveals it in great display when he feels safe to do so.

do I have to explain Trevor?


every mechanic inside the game has already been done better with their older counterparts
being able to greet and antagonise you can already do that in bully. more in depth gameplay and choices, GTA 4, the story (half and half feeling for me) GTA 4 yet again, controls, gta San Andreas (mostly the game still kinda feels off when playing). if you want a game that really changes as you play, go play Deus Ex, if you want more in depth characters go play the MGS games. Play fallout for the honor system if you enjoyed it in RDR2. if you want more everything, even in details play Half-Life 2


The horse mechanics feel awful and the survival mechanics aren't really that good I wish they we're more in depth.


When I went through my playthrough with good honor, the ending pulled on my heart strings only once, when my horse died. WHHYYYYYYY I enjoyed it a lot first, then I replayed it, my opinion completely flipped knowning nothing changed at all and the choices lie to me. while also realizing that the game is so strict on what you can do. third playthrough I started to count how many follow missions there are I counted 63 before I lost count in my head.
chapter 1 and 5 ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ suck, and I started to respect playing as john marston more, it felt better even though it was more strict. probably because there's LESS FOLLOWING MISSIONS.

the camp system does not matter

horse mechanics feel sluggish at best, at worst you have to tap A constantly, If i remember correctly R* they removed that in games because it would hurt people who have hand problems. like it was so constant that it broke my PS4 controller.

Micah, Most people hated him for being annoying, I hate him because He's so one dimensional that every other personality trait he has is not shown once. people act like he's so good as a bad guy but at no point is it shown why he's bad or shown any good to give you hope hes good

dutch is a good villian but you are not telling me the same guy (who's been here for 6 months) that everyone hates at camp convinced him that his own step children are betraying him like cmon this is just lazy writing.

Pros:
I like the story well

the characters are good with little screentime they have

the heists feel amazing

its time accurate

the online "was" fun

melee combat is amazing

you can pet dogs

hunting is fun

chapter 4 and 6

chapter 3's ending

the jack marston plots

soundtrack is awesome

the game looks good
-----------------------------



for a game that critically acclaimed the game is going through an identity crisis on what it wants to be
strict or open, gameplay or details.
the game is alright on first playthrough, although its not for everyone note I say first playthrough

Love the game
but the PC port is really REALLY REALLY really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really ♥♥♥♥

pc port is still better than FNV's

i think i had 200 hours on ps4

I'll miss this game

still holds up to this day, also better than new tales

Shallow company but instead you cant run at all

saves dont work

all workers do is yap yap yap its ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ annoying just do the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ work

so many not good servers cough cough (northmen)