i'm just 20Hrs playthrough just acquired lordvessel for Firelink Shrine, this has much YES and NO.. i just want to point as Neutral (Between Recommended and not recommended), pro and cons encountered as follows:

-Bugs still exist when you defeated smough on 1st phase, Ornstein on 2nd phase charge you toward Gwn Statue, then He got stuck inside Gwyn Statue... ridiculous.. can't even progress unless warping back to last bonfire.
-Chain backstab on PvP inluding not limited to when you're entering Boss area (fogwall), Weird Invader still can backtab you will entering fog animation....sigh..
-gameplay still felt the same (inlcuding blightown 60fps)
-lag input and hitbox register wayy more than 5 meters from invader
-Should've been free with DS PTDE owner, not charge by $20 for 4K reso and HD Textures patch.
-Forget about textures, Animation still 100% Same
-Knight Lautrec escaped by Himself... idk how..
-Had some problem with my online friend for Jolly Co-op, using password 4-5 times sign unable to be seen, within 15 mins only 1-2 times successful co-op attempt.
- PvP seems not balance unlike its Successor (DS II, DS III)

+Solid 60 FPS playthrough including Blightown poisonuous fest area
+Online Revitalised
+HD textures can only be seen by zoom in to character details, when from distant still look blurry just like DS1 PTDE
+Still fun on Jolly Co-op,

All in all this is still DS PTDE, exact game only patch for HD Textures and Solid 60FPS not even remastered, more like DS PTDE HD Version.

will update soon after defeating Lord Gwyn? depends...

Recommended if you're never playing DS 1 PTDE yet for $40

protip: savedata can be backup manually, just in case your save data corrupted, just Copy/Paste savedata outside the savedata folder.

i'm just 20Hrs playthrough just acquired lordvessel for Firelink Shrine, this has much YES and NO.. i just want to point as Neutral (Between Recommended and not recommended), pro and cons encountered as follows: -Bugs still exist when you defeated smough on 1st phase, Ornstein on 2nd phase charge you toward Gwn Statue, then He got stuck inside Gwyn Statue... ridiculous.. can't even progress unless warping back to last bonfire. -Chain backstab on PvP inluding not limited to when you're entering Boss area (fogwall), Weird Invader still can backtab you will entering fog animation....sigh.. -gameplay still felt the same (inlcuding blightown 60fps) -lag input and hitbox register wayy more than 5 meters from invader -Should've been free with DS PTDE owner, not charge by $20 for 4K reso and HD Textures patch. -Forget about textures, Animation still 100% Same -Knight Lautrec escaped by Himself... idk how.. -Had some problem with my online friend for Jolly Co-op, using password 4-5 times sign unable to be seen, within 15 mins only 1-2 times successful co-op attempt. - PvP seems not balance unlike its Successor (DS II, DS III) +Solid 60 FPS playthrough including Blightown poisonuous fest area +Online Revitalised +HD textures can only be seen by zoom in to character details, when from distant still look blurry just like DS1 PTDE +Still fun on Jolly Co-op, All in all this is still DS PTDE, exact game only patch for HD Textures and Solid 60FPS not even remastered, more like DS PTDE HD Version. will update soon after defeating Lord Gwyn? depends... Recommended if you're never playing DS 1 PTDE yet for $40 protip: savedata can be backup manually, just in case your save data corrupted, just Copy/Paste savedata outside the savedata folder.