maybe like this:
hold altfire to carge

+25% damage while carging
-15% damage
-10% movement speed while cargeing

-Causes bleed for two seconds
+%50 attack speed
+Crits after 4th consectuive hit (cannot crit buildings)
-%75 Less Damage vs players and buildings
-Doesn't crit randomly

(+)
5 sec of bleeding after hit
Mini crits when you have -25HP

(-)
-15% slower moving when you holing gun
-35% damage

I feel it could have kind of a a fuel system. It would do 15 damage per hit, but while you have fuel, it would do this damage, but at a f*cking ludicrous rate, so you jnust SAW THREW THOSE ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥!!! But with no fuel, you just wack people with a flimsy sawblade on a stick... Unimpresing. You get fuel from ammo, like any other weapon. You can fully drain the fuel in about 5 seconds, but you can pickup someone's weapon, and do this for a bit longer... Just don't get cocky.

+ 80% attack rate with fuel

- 70% damage

this "gun" is awesome.. well.. this 'gun' sucks. Frying pan is best gun.

Originalmente postado por Personal Pan Pizzas (SWE):

maybe like this:
hold altfire to carge

+25% damage while carging
-15% damage
-10% movement speed while cargeing

Let me see here

Pros
+Bleed for 5 seconds
+Steal 20% of the person's health
+10 damage
+More heads faster swing speed, and movement speed (cause it decapitates people)

Cons
-25 health
-25% of speed
-no random crits

Not a stat but Crit animation would swing forward (like it does now) or sideways

Stats:

Pros:
Each hit fills a meter by 20%
When meter is full, +40% resistance from all forces, +20% swing speed, Crits and "you just SAW THREW THOSE ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥S"

Cons:
-38% damage (40 damage)

Statistics for the Skull Saw

+ 30 Damage
+ Bleed for 5 seconds
+ Skull Saw deals an additional 15 damage if the Medic is below 30% health
- 25 Health
- 10% Speed
- Skull Saw can harm the user if attack misses only when the Medic is below 40% health

..........................................................................................................................................................
(Spinning is the equivilent of rapidly firing with the bonesaw. That means it is essentially a melee minigun. Adjust the stats based on how fast it fires)

20% longer weapon switch
No random critical hits
Hold fire to spin

When spinning:
-20% movement speed
15% damage vulnerability
!!!!(Seriously read the paragraph before you start with " Where are the bonuses! " )!!!!


Spinning is rapidly firing right? You should adjust the stats based on how fast it fires. Some weapons have stats that aren't mentioned or are not thoroughly explained. The spinning is the equivilent of firing a bonesaw (which is the base of Medic's melee weapon damage) every half or quarter of a second. If you raised the damage higher, you are talking about an extra lethal bonesaw that strikes multiple times in less than a second. That could insta-kill anyone.The weapon switch time penalty is to prevent people from switching to another weapon and back to ignore the movement penalty. The damage vulnerability is so you don't have to remove as much speed, and helps give other players a chance to fight back. So balance the firing rate and melee damage with Medic's movement speed and damage vulnerability. If it is still unbalanced, try a damage penalty or bonus.
..........................................................................................................................................................

+bleed for 5 sec on hit
+alt-fire: charges for 5 sec to deal a critical hit
+25% firing rate
+25% damage
-no random crits
-30% longer weapon switch
-10 HP on wearer

Originalmente postado por ThePersonalPizza:

maybe like this:
hold altfire to carge

+25% damage while carging
-15% damage
-10% movement speed while cargeing

i would use that

(+)a legit reskin of the bonesaw
(+)gibs opponents on kill leaving a brief blood particles just like The Classic
(-)no negative stats

Originalmente postado por Johannes W. Mozart | trade.tf:

Let me see here

Pros
+Bleed for 5 seconds
+Steal 20% of the person's health
+10 damage
+More heads faster swing speed, and movement speed (cause it decapitates people)

Cons
-25 health
-25% of speed
-no random crits

25% slower hit speed
if you have ubered you get 25% more damage and have the same effect of that uber on your self