yeah! left click: melee
right click: throw

great idea

It Kinda Ruins The Whole Secondary Idea

The idea of a stab would completely ruin scout. The Guillotine for scout is much more balanced because if you miss, it's gone for some time. having a melee for your secondary would just be too op, and having a melee that can also hit from long distance would again be op.

Im think will better if you can put in secondary(to trow) and in melee.

Maybe it could atke up both Melee and Secondary slots. Press alt-fire to change between those. If in melee, left click to swing. Everything like normal bat. If in secondary, cats like a Flying guilottine, with the exception of crits on stunned targets. The crits would be random, and set to damage dealt with both of those weapons. Kinda like the idea i've seen on one of Karma Charger's video with the shotgun-axe pyro weapon.

What about the Cleaver gets the 2 in 1 treatment(melee and throwable)and the Bloodletter is a sword/machete version of that? Cleaver is a heavy knife, just so you know.

Also, I think that on melee the cleaver and the Bloodleter should give you HP that overheals.

This is a good contrast of melee vs ranged. Do you want HP on kill that overheals on melee kills or do you want ranged damage with bleed?

And If you are wondering where is the downside, the whole melee vs ranged and the fact that as a Scout it is a high risk high reward playstyle with melee bits.

I should probably put this idea in my thread for the Bloodletter stats.

Also, what do you think about having some weapons of the Scout that can be in more than one slot.

The example related to this thread is Cleaver either in Secondary and/or melee slot(note: if in two slots, you get double the item).

this way you could have the Pistol and the cleaver/bloodletter as a loadout.

I think that the Shortstop could be an secondary weapon as well.

No flaming and/or trolling please and thank you.