To begin the adventure of finding these various trinkets, players need to first max out all skill levels to the maximum of 10. Only after that will they be able to unlock the masteries as late-game content.

The Mastery Cave will be open after the previous step is complete. The location of the Mastery Cave is in the bottom right area of Cindersap Forest. Near the sewer and the area where wild spring onions grow, a door will be located on a rock wall that is slightly hidden by a tree. Once inside, there will be pillars to expand on the five skill sets further to mastery by using mastery experience points. These points are earned through the same methods of skill leveling from before by tools and actions in gameplay.

The Masteries don't need to be done in order, so it is possible to go for the Combat pillar first if desired. The Combat Mastery will provide the recipes to make an Anvil and Mini-Forge and unlock a new slot for trinkets. This new slot will be on the main menu, placed next to where players can equip hats, and the spot will have a star icon when nothing is equipped. Crafting the Anvil is recommended for the Trinkets. (See #5 further below)

All of the trinkets with the exception of one (The Magic Hair Gel mentioned further in the guide) can be found through monster drops, Skull Cavern treasure rooms, and small chances of crates and barrels. Daily luck and luck buffs will affect drop chances. It is possible to obtain the same trinket multiple times, but it is not possible to stack any buffs from the trinkets nor is it possible to merge them. They are treated like weapons and armor that will not go in shipping bins and have to get sold at the Adventurer's Guild.

Before you decide to toss out a trinket for poor stats, consider re-rolling them! The Anvil can be crafted at the cost of 50 iron bars. This item will allow random re-rolls of the stats/appearance of Trinkets to a extent. There is specific limitations with each Trinket, for example, re-rolling the frog egg will change the frog's appearance whereas the fairy box will have the stats changed instead of the fairy's looks. The only two trinkets that will not apply to this are the Basilisk Paw and the Magic Hair Gel. Each re-roll involves putting the Trinket on the Anvil with 3 Iridium Bars. The result is random and there is no limit to the amount of re-rolls on a Trinket.

Note: It is possible to gift Trinkets to villagers and preferences for liking and disliking said items still apply, they are not universally loved items

When equipped, a frog is summoned and will follow the player around, appearing in whatever color specified when found. The frog will attempt to eat monsters close by and make attempts every 2 seconds if it fails. When the frog does catch a monster, the frog will immediately consume it including invulnerable ones such as the mummies and armored bugs. There is a 12 second cool down before the frog is allowed to make another attempt at eating monsters. The frog will not give any monster drops from those it eats and these kills do not count towards the Monster Eradication Goals. This trinket comes in handy for dungeons that have mobs of enemies or ranged monsters that are harder to reach like serpents from the Skull Caverns or monsters separated by lava in the Volcano Dungeons.

When equipped, a fairy is summoned and will follow the player around with a healing interval of 4.7 secs to 3.5 secs at the highest level. The fairy will only heal the player when they are in combat, not engaging with monsters or waiting in dungeon levels will not provide passive healing. This trinket can be extremely helpful in the Mines, Skull Cavern, or the Volcano Dungeon when dealing with mobs of enemies. There is still a need to be careful for the regeneration of health will not always recover at the same rate of taking damage, but could be useful in regaining health back before consuming food items.

The fairy's level can be changed by the anvil, however the visual style of the fairy is determined by the player's save file and player slot (multiplayer).

When equipped, a parrot similar to the ones on Ginger Island is summoned and will follow the player around. The parrot will only work when the player is in combat and upon killing monsters, drop gold coins that will be added to the player's earnings. The amount of profit gain from the parrot is dependent on the level of the parrot and the total earrings of the player. This Trinket is more helpful in grinding in areas like the Mines against weak monsters due to being less combat oriented like the other Companion Trinkets.

The Basilisk Paw, when equipped, makes players immune to all debuffs caused by enemies. It will not prevent any self-inflicted debuffs like Tipsy. Players will find this Trinket useful for fighting relentless monsters that inflict debuffs to hinder progress. This is one of the two Trinkets that can not be forged on an Anvil.

When equipped, the Golden Spur will give the player Speed(+1) on every critical strike. This Trinket could be helpful in moving away from monsters in combat or increasing maneuvering around ones like Pepper Rexs.

Equipping the Ice Rod causes a ice orb to occasionally fire, directed at the nearest enemy to the player in 9-10 tile radius. This ice orb will freeze all monsters in its path for a brief amount of time, but will not cause damage. This Trinket comes in handy for those combating a overwhelming mob of monsters looking for a quick chance to breathe.

There is a 5% chance of Trinket dropping/reforged to become the "Perfect Ice Rod with the max stats allowed"

The Magic Hair Gel is the only trinket to be more of a cosmetic. When equipped, the player's hair will cycle through the colors of a prismatic shard with no other buff given. As such, this trinket is one of the two ones unable to be re-forged on the anvil. The method of obtaining this elusive trinket is a bit harder than the others for it's only available within a specific window of time.

The Desert Festival happens every year from Spring 15-17th with two villagers randomly selected each day to host their shops with the festival's currency of Calico Eggs. This currency can be carried over the three days of the festival but will disappear after the event is over. The Magic Hair Gel will only be sold by Alex at the price of 100 Calico Eggs.

The Magic Quiver will shoot the first monster in its path, including overlapping ones, when equipped. There is a radius of effectiveness around the player of 7-8 tiles as to when a magic arrow will fire off when monsters are near and there is a limit to the frequency and duration. The magic arrows do a small bit of knockback and there are four different types available; None, Perfect, Rapid, and Heavy, that will determine the stats. This Trinket works very well for any players hoping to passively chip away at monsters health during combat.