The Wolf Among Us

The Wolf Among Us

224 ratings
100% Achievement Guide: The Wolf Among Us
By Cynic 0055
This is a comprehensive 100% Achievement guide detailing a step-by-step walkthrough to take you from 0 all the way to 100%. If you are looking for a particular Achievement or Collectible, use Ctrl+F & type it into the search bar for more direct help.

I run support & debug help on all my guides. If you have any questions, problems, or find errors in the guide itself, do not hesitate to leave me a comment & I will get back to you as soon as I am able to. Happy Hunting!
3
14
3
2
   
Award
Favorite
Favorited
Unfavorite
Introduction:

Achievement Breakdown: (35)
Story Related: (30)
Collectibles: (5)


Book of Fables:
Episode 1: 21 Entries
Episode 2: 11 Entries
Episode 3: 11 Entries
Episode 4: 12 Entries
Episode 5: 8 Entries


The majority of the Book of Fables entries can be earned naturally during your first playthrough of the game, most are all Story Related & cannot be missed. There are only 14 entries that will require a specific decision for. If you miss an entry, you can reload individual Chapters after beating the Episode they are found on. You can quit the Chapter as soon as you unlock the entry.

*This guide contains minor spoilers.
Sequence 1: Faith
1. Complete Chapters 1-6 of Episode 1
2. Unlock all 19 Story Related Book of Fables entries
3. Unlock the 2 Missable Book of Fables entries in Chapter 6 (Need to replay Chapter to unlock alternate entry).

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter #1: Disturbance

Entry #1 – Bigby Wolf: This entry is unlocked after you finish your conversation with Mr. Toad at the start of the Chapter.

Entry #7 – Mr. Toad: This entry is unlocked after you finish your conversation with Mr. Toad at the start of the Chapter.

Entry #11 – Fabletown: This entry is unlocked after you finish your conversation with Mr. Toad at the start of the Chapter.

Entry #12 – The Farm: This entry is unlocked after you finish your conversation with Mr. Toad at the start of the Chapter.

Entry #14 – Glamour’s: This entry is unlocked after you finish your conversation with Mr. Toad at the start of the Chapter.

Entry #3 – The Woodsman: This entry is unlocked after you deal with The Woodsman.


Achievement #1 – Welcome to Fabletown: Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 1
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #2: The Woodlands

Entry #5 – Beauty: This entry is unlocked after you finish your conversation with Sleeping Beauty at the start of the Chapter.

Entry #6 – Beast: This entry is unlocked when you first encounter Beast in the elevator.

Entry #19 – Bluebeard: While in Bigby’s apartment, leave the kitchen & walk over to the desk. Reading the file labeled “Bluebeard” will unlock this entry. I assume this entry is also unlocked when you meet Bluebeard in person later in this Episode...

Entry #2 – Snow White: This entry is unlocked during your conversation with Colin the Pig.

Entry #8 – Colin: This entry is unlocked during your conversation with Colin the Pig.


Achievement #2 – Wolf in Sheriff’s Clothing: Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 1
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #3: Mirror Mirror

Entry #13 – Mundies: This entry is unlocked after discovering "The Plot" outside your apartment.


Achievement #3 – The Long Goodbye: Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 1
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #4: Choices

Entry #9 – Ichabod Crane: This entry is unlocked after meeting Ichabod Crane for the first time.

Entry #10 – Bufkin: This entry is unlocked after meeting Bufkin for the first time.

Entry #4 – Faith: This entry is unlocked after discovering who "The Plot" is.


Achievement #4 – The Frog or the Prince?: Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 1
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #5: Consequences

Entry #15 – Prince Lawrence: This entry is unlocked after meeting Prince Lawrence for the first time.

Entry #16 – The Tweedles: This entry is unlocked after meeting The Tweedle Brothers for the first time.


Achievement #5 – Panic In the Parlours: Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 1
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #6: Trip Trap


Entry #17 – Holly: This entry is unlocked after meeting Holly the bar tender for the first time.

Entry #18 – Grendel: This entry is unlocked after meeting Grendel in the bar for the first time.

Entry #20 (Missable) – The Tweedles: This entry is unlocked after choosing the peaceful
ending to your fight in the bar.

Entry #21 (Missable) – Bigby’s Revenge: This entry is unlocked after choosing the violent ending to your fight in the bar.


Achievement #6 – A Light Snowfall: Completed Episode 1: Faith
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of Chapter 6.


Achievement #7 – Novice Librarian: Unlocked all 21 Book of Fables entries in Episode 1
You will be able to unlock 20 of the 21 Fables entries in one playthrough. In the beginning of Chapter 6 you will get into a bar fight & have two options with how to end it: walk away or tearing off your opponents’ arm. Each decision has an associated Book of Fables entry. You can only replay Chapters after completing the entire Episode.
Sequence 2: Smoke & Mirrors
1. Complete Chapters 1-6 of Episode 2
2. Unlock all 11 Story Related Book of Fables entries
3. Unlock the 2 Missable Book of Fables entries in Chapter 2 (Need to replay Chapter to unlock alternate entry)
4. Unlock the 2 Missable Book of Fables entries in Chapter 3
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter #1: Grief


Achievement #8 – Right to an Attorney: Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 2
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fable entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #2: Wrath

Entry #22 (Missable) – Ichabod’s Denial: This entry is unlocked if you complete the interrogation as “bad cop Bigby”. Choose only violent responses, not passive ones & Crane will stop you unlocking his entry. You will need to replay this Chapter for the other entry.

Entry #23 (Missable) – Bluebeard’s Mercy: This entry is unlocked if you complete the interrogation as “good cop Bigby”. Choose only passive responses, not violent ones & Bluebeard will stop you unlocking this entry. You will need to replay this Chapter for the other entry.


Achievement #9 – Breaking Point: Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 2
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #3: Blood

Entry #25 (Missable) – Magic Mirror: This entry is technically missable if you do not speak to the Mirror on the Wall in this Chapter. When the Chapter begins, you will see Mr. Toad & his son speaking to the Mirror. Finish the conversation with them, but when "The Plot" asks you to leave & examine the body, stick around & go speak with the Mirror instead. Ask him what the Toad’s were looking at to unlock this entry.

Entry #26 (Missable) – The Witching Well: When you regain control of Bigby after leaving to examine the body with "The Plot", turn to your left & approach the large well. Interacting with it will unlock this entry.

Entry #24 – Thirteenth Floor: This entry is unlocked during your conversation with "The Plot" while investigating the body.

Entry #27 – Jack Horner: This entry is unlocked after meeting Jack in the Trip Trap Bar for the first time.

Entry #28 – Lily: This entry is unlocked after leaving the Trip Trap Bar at the end of the Chapter.

Entry #29 – Troll Cross: This entry is unlocked after leaving the Trip Trap Bar with "The Plot" at the end of the Chapter.


Achievement #10 – Sisters: Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 2
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #4: Skin

Entry #30 – Georgie Porgie: This entry is unlocked after meeting Georgie for the first time at the Pudding & Pie.

Entry #31 – Clever Hans: This entry is unlocked after meeting Hans for the first time at the Pudding & Pie.

Entry #32 – Nerissa: This entry is unlocked after meeting The Little Mermaid for the first time at the Pudding & Pie.


Achievement #11 – Made Them Cry: Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 2
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #5: Secrets


Achievement #12 – Can I Get A Fresh Set of Towels: Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 2
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #6: Revelations


Achievement #13 – No Respect For the Dead: Completed Chapter 6 of Episode 2
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of Chapter 6. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.


Achievement #14 – Apprentice Librarian: Unlocked all 11 Book of Fables entries in Episode 2
You will be able to unlock 10 of the 11 Fables entries in one playthrough. In the beginning of Chapter 2 you will be interrogating a suspect & have two options with how to deal with it: violently or passively. Each decision has an associated Book of Fables entry. You can only replay Chapters after completing the entire Episode.
Sequence 3: The Crooked Mile
1. Complete Chapters 1-6 of Episode 3
2. Unlock all 7 Story Related Book of Fables entries
3. Unlock the 1 Missable Book of Fables entry in Chapter 2
4. Unlock the 1 Missable Book of Fables entry in Chapter 3
5. Unlock the 2 Missable Book of Fables entries in Chapter 5 (Need to replay Chapter to unlock alternate entry)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter #1: Windy Nights


Achievement #15 – Promising Leads: Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 3
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #2: Marching Song

Entry #33 (Missable) – Troll Funeral Rites: When the Chapter begins, approach the funeral ceremony. You will have the option of interrupting or waiting till it ends. Do not interrupt & instead, walk over directly to your left & head to the offering table. There are four objects to interact with: a bottle of Billy Goat whiskey & three notes. The first note after the whiskey will be one from Holly to Lily. After reading it, you will unlock this entry.

Entry #34 – Vivian: This entry is unlocked after speaking with "The Plot" & Nerissa during Lily’s funeral when Vivian asks for them to witness the burning ceremony.


Achievement #16– Belly Full of Stones: Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 3
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #3: Travel

Entry #35 – Dr. Swineheart: This entry is unlocked after meeting Dr. Swineheart for the first time.

At the end of Chapter 3 we will have three options for us to go & investigate. Choose to investigate the apartment first. There are 2 missable entries in the next Chapter that we would have to replay it for if we miss them by not going there first...


Achievement #17 – What Big Eyes You Have: Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 3
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #4: My Kingdom

Entry #37 (Missable) – Headless Horseman: This entry is unlocked if you investigate the apartment first. Upon finding the door open & heading inside make your way to the far-left corner of the room. On top of a desk, is a golden statue of the Headless Horseman. Interacting with it will unlock the Book of Fables entry.

Choose the offices as the second place to investigate to find the other Missable Entry for this Chapter.

Entry #36 (Missable) – Flycatcher: This entry is unlocked after speaking with Flycatcher as you leave the offices.

Entry #38 – The Trip Trap Bar: This entry is unlocked after discovering “A.G.”s address while at the Trip Trap Bar.


Achievement #18– Huff & Puff: Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 3
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #5: Happy Thoughts

Entry #39 – Auntie Greenleaf: This entry is unlocked after meeting Auntie Greenleaf for the first time.

Entry #41 (Missable) – Glamour Tube: At the end of the Chapter we will have the option of burning Auntie Greenleaf’s tree or leaving it alone. This entry is unlocked for leaving the tree alone. We will have to replay this Chapter to unlock the alternate entry.

Entry #40 (Missable) – Glamour Tree: At the end of the Chapter we will have the option of burning Auntie Greenleaf’s tree or leaving it alone. This entry is unlocked for burning the tree. We will have to replay this Chapter to unlock the alternate entry.


Achievement #19 – Severe Case of Lycanthropy: Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 3
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #6: My Shadow

Entry #42 – Ring of Dispel: This entry is unlocked after Crane fails to use the Ring of Dispel at the Pudding & Pie.

Entry #43 – Bloody Mary: This entry is unlocked at the end of Chapter 6.


Achievement #20 – The Enchanted Land of New York City: Completed Chapter 6 of Episode 3
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of Chapter 6.


Achievement #21 – Journeyman Librarian: Unlocked all 11 Book of Fables entries in Episode 3
You will be able to unlock 10 of the 11 Fables entries in one playthrough. At the end of Chapter 5 you will be interrogating Auntie Greenleaf & have two options with how to deal with it: burning the tree or leaving it alone. Each decision has an associated Book of Fables entry. You can only replay Chapters after completing the entire Episode.
Sequence 4: In Sheep's Clothing
1. Complete Chapters 1-6 of Episode 4
2. Unlock all 9 Story Related Book of Fables entries
3. Unlock the 2 Missable Book of Fables entry in Chapter 3
4. Unlock the 1 Missable Book of Fables entry in Chapter 4
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter #1: House Call

Entry #44 – Silver Bullets: This entry is unlocked during the beginning scene of Chapter 1.

Entry #45 – Acting Deputy: This entry is unlocked during the beginning scene of Chapter 1.

Entry #55 – Life on the Farm: This entry is unlocked during the beginning scene of Chapter 1.


Achievement #22 – Once Upon A Time: Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 4
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #2: Past Due

During Chapter 2, you will eventually get to choose where to investigate first: The Lucky Pawn or the Cut Above. Choosing the Lucky Pawn first will unlock a missable Book of Fables entry & save you having to replay the Chapter.


Achievement #23 – There Was A Wolf: Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 4
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #3: Hard Case

Entry #46 (Missable) – Donkey Skin Coat: This entry is unlocked only if you choose to go to the Lucky Pawn first in Chapter 2.

Entry #47 (Missable) – Briar Rose: This entry is unlocked only if you choose to go to the Lucky Pawn first in Chapter 2. When Jack begins closing shop, you will gain control of Bigby. On the right side of the room there are two glass cases. One contains a Crystal Ball & the other is a Pin Cushion. Interacting with the Pin Cushion will unlock the entry. Be sure to find it before Interacting with the empty display case on the far left of the shop which will progress the Chapter.

Entry #48 – The Jersey Devil: This entry is unlocked at the Lucky Pawn in Chapter 3 or 4.

Entry #49 – Woodsman’s Axe: This entry is unlocked at the Lucky Pawn in Chapter 3 or 4.


Achievement #24 – Who Ruled the Land: Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 4
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. This will unlock when you finish investigating either the Lucky Pawn or The Cut Above.

Chapter #4: Cut Deep

Entry #50 (Missable) – Johann: This entry is unlocked only if you choose to go to the Lucky Pawn first in Chapter 2 & The Cut Above second. It unlocks at the end of the Chapter.


Achievement #25 – He Was Much Feared: Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 4
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. This will unlock when you finish investigating either the Lucky Pawn or The Cut Above.

Chapter #5: Piece Together

Entry #51 – Bluebeard’s Money: This entry is unlocked at the beginning of Chapter 5.


Achievement #26 – But Soon He Mended His Evil Ways: Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 4
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #6: Come Knocking

Entry #52 – The Crooked Lair: This entry is unlocked at the when you meet… "The Plot".

Entry #53 – The Crooked Man: This entry is unlocked at the when you meet… "The Plot".

Entry #54 – Tiny Tim: This entry is unlocked at the when you meet… "The Plot".


Achievement #27 – And All Were Happy: Completed Chapter 6 of Episode 4
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of Chapter 6.


Achievement #28 – Master Librarian: Unlocked all 12 Book of Fables entries in Episode 4
You will be able to unlock all 12 of the Fables entries in one playthrough but only if you choose to go to the Lucky Pawn first at the end of Chapter 2. You can only replay Chapters after completing the entire Episode.
Sequence 5: Cry Wolf
1. Complete Chapters 1-6 of Episode 5
2. Unlock all 7 Story Related Book of Fables entries
3. Unlock the 1 Missable Book of Fables entry in Chapter 3
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter #1: The Chapel


Achievement #29 – The Beginning of the End: Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 5
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #2: Out In the Open


Achievement #30 – This House of Straw: Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 5
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #3: Vagabonds

Entry #56 – Vivian’s Story: This entry is unlocked after resolving Vivian’s Plot.

Entry #57 – The Pudding N’ Pie: This entry is unlocked after resolving Georgie’s Plot.

Entry #58 (Missable) – Winter Wolf: When you reach Sheppard Metalworks, make your way through the building & investigate the work bench. In the following conversation with Bloody Mary you will have 4 options to choose from: "Cut the (censored by Steam)," "I'm talking to you!", "[Hit her]", or "...(silence)".

Keep the conversation going with either "Cut the (censored by Steam)" or "I'm talking to you!” to unlock this entry about Bigby’s mother.

Entry #59 – The Big Bad Wolf: This entry is unlocked at the end of the Chapter.

Entry #60 – Mary’s Loyalty: This entry is unlocked at the end of the Chapter.


Achievement #31 – A Silver Bullet: Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 5
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #4: Face to Face



Achievement #32 – My Last Cigarette: Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 5
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter. There are no Book of Fables entries in this Chapter.

Chapter #5: On Fairness

Entry #61 – Fabletown Justice: This entry is unlocked at the end of the Chapter.


Achievement #33 – The North Wind Blows: Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 5
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of the Chapter.

Chapter #6: The Life of a Good-For-Nothing

Entry #62 – A New Order: This entry is unlocked at the beginning of the Chapter.

Entry #63 – Sheriff Bigby: This entry is unlocked after saying goodbye to Mr. Toad & his son TJ.


Achievement #34 – Happily Ever After: Completed Chapter 6 of Episode 5
Story Related. The Achievement will unlock at the end of Chapter 6.


Achievement #35 – Grand Master Librarian: Unlocked all 8 Book of Fables entries in Episode 5
You will be able to unlock all 8 of the Fables entries in one playthrough but only if you choose to keep the conversation going with Bloody Mary in Chapter 3. You can only replay Chapters after completing the entire Episode.
Conclusion:
One of easiest & most enjoyable 100%'s I have ever earned, it took me approximately 11 hours to complete this. If this guide helped you achieve 100%, rate the guide or let me know in the comments. Helps me know if I am doing things right!


100% Complete!
Thank you for choosing Cynic, & I will see you in the next guide!

If you are interested in a little bit of patronage, support my projects & consider buying me a beer. If not, no worries; my guides are, & will always be free content. Achievement Hunting is my passion, & writing these guides is a way for me to give meaning to a life long hobby!
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/cynic0055

If you enjoy my style of writing guides, be sure to check out my profile for a full list of my works.

15 Comments
Argylle 18 Aug @ 4:22am 
Thank you sir, for the help!
Catslug 16 Apr @ 4:09am 
haha "among us" haha
Mariavkj 22 Dec, 2023 @ 8:43pm 
thx
SparksV 26 Nov, 2023 @ 6:41pm 
Thanks for making this👏 Helped me hunt down the last 5 achievements I needed for 100% (all for missed book of fables entries). Informative and very easy to follow guide.
Division 25 Sep, 2023 @ 4:29am 
Very good guide I followed everything to 100% before I completed the story. Also you have a typo on Achievement #33, Aachievement. Hope Season 2 will deliver something better at least.
CindyK_JA 22 Apr, 2023 @ 7:46am 
Thank you for the time you put into this guide. Will be helpful in picking up anything missed once I complete the episodes!
Hiro 13 Jan, 2023 @ 10:43am 
Good guide. It was useful to 100% this game. Thanks
ZoeperJ 31 Dec, 2022 @ 2:07pm 
Very helpful.
TheMemeist 14 Jul, 2022 @ 3:00pm 
Thanks man i beat this on my first run thanks to your guide.:peace_hoi:
Eruri Waifu 27 Jun, 2022 @ 7:39pm 
Thanks!