Good -
Arguably the best story in all of gaming
Most Detailed open world environment
greatest side missions out there
Decent enough AI
Easy to immerse yourself in the environment
widely interactable animals
Decent enough modding scene

The Bad-
Horrible online (Hackers with access to your address type of bad)
Bugs that aren't getting fixed in which some even affect the main campaign
The traversal is boring
Some missions have you travel from one place to another, in which it limits your horse speed which makes the already mid traversal even worse

Mixed-
The combat can get stale, however mods can make it a bit better
John Marston's model was rushed, doesn't necessarily look awful but it really could look better

Good - Arguably the best story in all of gaming Most Detailed open world environment greatest side missions out there Decent enough AI Easy to immerse yourself in the environment widely interactable animals Decent enough modding scene The Bad- Horrible online (Hackers with access to your address type of bad) Bugs that aren't getting fixed in which some even affect the main campaign The traversal is boring Some missions have you travel from one place to another, in which it limits your horse speed which makes the already mid traversal even worse Mixed- The combat can get stale, however mods can make it a bit better John Marston's model was rushed, doesn't necessarily look awful but it really could look better