Dude, it's Bioshock. Asking "Why did you like this game" is akin to asking why people enjoyed Pac-Man, Super Mario Bros., Zelda, Myst, Doom, Halo, or any other classic game. They are (were) the ground-breakers.

I look forward to the next new "innovative" title as much as the next gamer, but if this isn't in your collection, well, it's as if I'm talking to someone who's never seen "Star Wars". I just don't understand how to have that conversation and consider you an actual gamer.

Even if you hated it, you've played it. Right?

Dude, it's Bioshock. Asking "Why did you like this game" is akin to asking why people enjoyed Pac-Man, Super Mario Bros., Zelda, Myst, Doom, Halo, or any other classic game. They are (were) the ground-breakers. I look forward to the next new "innovative" title as much as the next gamer, but if this isn't in your collection, well, it's as if I'm talking to someone who's never seen "Star Wars". I just don't understand how to have that conversation and consider you an actual gamer. Even if you hated it, you've played it. Right?