Recent reviews by BVERailer

Nice set of locos, decent sounds, too. It would be better if some freight cars were included, but overall nice selection of locomotives.

The overall route extension is good, the rolling stock.. not so much.

Pros of Route: Cons of Route:
-Full length Caltrain route - Can't find any
-Adds more freight trackage
-Scenery is more realistic that SF-SJ
-More accomodation for Amtrak usage (Santa Clara
to Gilroy)

Pros of Rolling Stock: Cons of Rolling Stock:
-Adds all forms of CT commuter equipment -F40PH has no bell, doesn't work when pressing the B button or
clicking the bell button
-Good selection of freight stock -F40PH throttle and braking physics are terrible, brakes take too
-Gallery car has decent physics long to fully release, and braking system is annoying
-Keeps the MP36PH/Bilevel from old route -Gallery Car has E Bell, should have steel bell
-Gallery Car has correct horn (that's probably a first) -Bilevel cabcar has E Bell, should have steel bell
-Good passenger view for coaches -Only one freight locomotive
-Open-able doors in cabs of locomotives -F40PH has some foreign K5LA, should have a P2 like other
stock

If you have OCD about train physics, I wouldn't recommend it, if you just want it to experience Caltrain, I would recommend it. Hopefully someone makes a physics mod for the F40PH and MP36. Sounds can easily be fixed by finding a sound somewhere and editing the proxyxml.

Great route, can't wait for the Gilroy Extension with the F40PH and NS Gallery Cars. Two small bugs though;
-For the interior bell, you can hear a two bells, one E-Bell, the one that should be there, and a steel-bell sype bell, which should not be there.
-The horn recording isn't the best, it doesn't sound like a real Caltrain P2, and if you listen carefully to the exterior horn recording, you can hear someone shouting, "Woo!"

Otherwise, great route, I definitely recommend it.

Great route! Great scenery, and great selection of rolling stock, especially the Boeing fuselage flatcars. Definitely recommend it.

I bought this during the sale, and the freight cars aren't there! I don't know why some people have them, but others don't, but that is sort of the main reason I bought this. I was very disappointed to find this. I even checked the files for this addon, and nothing.