Here's my personal Top 10 story games so far, and all others I have played (I've added dates for when I first played them based on purchase date:

01: Batman: Arkham City - Oct 2015
02: What Remains of Edith Finch - Nov 2018
03: Batman: Arkham Asylum - Nov 2013
04: Bioshock Infinite - May 2018
05: Psychonauts - Dec 2018
06: Star Wars: Battlefront II -Nov 2024
07: Star Wars: Fallen Order - Jul 2022
08: Hollow Knight - Apr 2023
09: Portal 2 - Dec 2015
10: Bioshock - Apr 2018


Bastion - May 2020
Firewatch - Jul 2018
Grand Auto V - Jul 2019
Halo 3 - Feb 2022
Halo 3: ODST - Jan 2022
Halo 4 - Apr 2022
Halo Reach - Mar 2022
Hitman: Absolution - Aug 2023
Ori and the Blind Forest - Feb 2022
Orwell - Dec 2016
Portal - Dec 2014
Spongebob: Battle for Bikini Bottom Rehydrated - Jul 2020
Supraland - Jan 2021
Uncharted 4 (PS4) - Jan 2018
Wolfenstein: Old Blood - Jun 2020

Batman: Arkham Origins - Jul 2016
Dr. Langeskov, The Tiger, and The Terribly Cursed Emerald: A Whirlwind Heist - Jul 2018
Halo 2 - Nov 2021
INSIDE - Mar 2019
LEGO: Marvel Super Heroes - May 2014
LISA - Mar 2021
Outer Wilds - Nov 2022
Wolfenstein: The New Order - Jan 2019

A Story About My Uncle - Jan 2019
Batman: Arkham Knight - Jan 2017
Halo: CE - Jul 2021
Ori and the Will of the Wisps -Jun 2024

Her Story - Apr 2020
LIMBO - Feb 2019
The Fidelio Incident - Jul 2018
The Stanley Parable - Nov 2018

Bioshock 2 Remastered (endless game crashes - unplayable)
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (found out I don't enjoy open-world games)
Snake Pass (janky controls - would not recommend)
The Walking Dead: Telltale Series (didn't enjoy very much, finished Episode 1 only)
Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (re-tried open-world, still don't enjoy)
XCOM: Chimera Squad (not worth it - got bored)