Chalice. I remember early PC games having lots of chalices in them that you find as a treasure. 

map and level select 

wait a minute. there's no logical way forward! I have to guess. 

12 Locations to Solve to find Sherlock. 

Yes! It is SherloCAT Holmes! 

 

And here we go again. 

well it sort of looks like a book....with really LARGE TEXT! 

that's one wild candle 

It's called a Candlelabra! There were some of those in PC games I played as a young'un.