(Credits for Spookylicious for making the picture, you may find a link in the end of the guide for his profile)

SO, I had this great idea of making a guide about the different scout weapons. But many times MY opinion doesnt match the community opinion or is plain wrong. SO, I want you guys help. Post a opinion about different weapons in the comments, putting a score of 1 to 10 and a reason behind it, and also, though its optional, a good strategy with them. I will post it here, with other guys opinions so a new player can find easily a good weapon for his playstyle and also see what are the best and worst weapons overall. So dont just stand there maggot, come comment and help me. To start out I will put my opinion and score on each one.

Backscatter

Overall score: 4,8/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 5/10- ''A good concept badly used''

Mr.Beasty: 4/10-'' it's good when you can shoot everyone from the back, but when you're shooting at the front, it's not good''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 7/10- ''Its fun but needs a buff. A good one''

Dave: 8/10 - ''Shpee scout.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 1/10

Biohazard_Ferrett: 8,5- ''I like it in MvM and with the Atomizer.''

Landeyx: 0/10 "You're not a spy"

Voodoojazzoffire: 5/10- ''this is only a gun for sneak attacks, good to have if you have crit-a-cola if you want to be the spy scout, this is the gun for you''

Shortstop

Overall score: 5,5/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 4/10-''To used to other scatterguns to use an actual pistol and scatter mix''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 0/10-''Just the pushback is SO BAD. And only 4 bullets...''

Mr.Beasty: 1/10-''I don't even like this gun ._.''

Dave: 8/10- ''Ez good''

Landeyx: 10/10 "Deserves more attention"

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 6/10

lynxer13: 7/10-''Most people hate it but i like to use with the Crit-a-cola to give it some kick''

Voodoojazzoffire: 8/10- ''a very versatile weapon, only downside is it uses the primary spot, very good set if you use the milk''

Force a Nature

Overall score: 7/10
The Crazed Buttstaber: 5/10- ''Quite fun but the small clip size ruins it''

Mr.Beasty: 5/10- ''not bad, but not that good''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 6/10

AlphaStrategizer:8/10-A great weapon to use once you learn how to utilize its advantages properly, allowing you to get to hard to reach areas, and there are few more hilarious things then using knockback to annihilate heavies and force people off points.

Landeyx: 10/10 "PUSH PEOPLE MUHAHAHA

Voodoojazzoffire: 6/10- ''good despite the knockback and extra pellets, do not use from attacking from affar''

IWantMyRevolver| trade.tf: 9/10- ''Pretty great because that knockback can be devastating, you just have yo know when to use or your dead''

Soda Popper

Overall Score:7,5/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 7/10- ''I find it SO much fun. While it has a small clip size, it has a good reload ratio''

Mr.Beasty: 9/10- ''This is one of my favourite scout weapons, but the bad part it has a small clip size''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 4/10-''It has potencial but needs buffing. Like for example going back to the minicrits on pop''

Dave: 3/10 - ''Only use for Showing off your jumping skills. Otherwise, nah.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 9/10

Reven: 10/10-''must giv soda pop and sandy 10/10''

Landeyx: 10/10 "Annoy people by jumping over their heads"

Voodoojazzoffire: 8.5/10- ''its a very good weapon, only downside is it has -4 ammo in the gun but still, a very Awsome gun to have''

Baby Face Blaster

Overall score: 8/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 10/10- ''I love it to death. Its so much fun. I use it 24/7''

Mr.Beasty: 9/10- ''This gun is really good, another one of my favourite scout guns''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 8/10- ''Its good, but not THAT good''

Dave: 7/10-''Basically Speedhacks.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 9/10

Agent Walther: 10/10- "In love with that thing"

Landeyx: 0/10 "Why does this thing exist?"

Voodoojazzoffire: 10/10- ''this gun is an awsome gun, if you dont get shot, that is most unlikely, exept sentries, a scouts job is to kill and dodge, if you stand being shot all the time, you are doing it wrong, this is my favorite gun in my opinion, i dont know about the others, but yea.''

HyperFlare957: 9/10- ''I'd love to rate it higher, but Valve seems to ruin every single weapon. Take back that slowdown on hit!''

Scattergun

Overall score: 9,2/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 8/10- ''Stock is good, but I find it quite boring compared to others''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 10/10- ''Well, it has 6 bullets, and stock is always good''

Mr.Beasty: 10/10- ''Ok i use this gun and i will use it forever, if you get the botkiller one, it's amazing''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 10/10

Agent Walther: 7,5/10- "While it has the biggest clip size of all the primary Scout weapons, it's still pretty meh. Maybe it's just me too used to shortstop and bfb with their accuracy, but i feel myself uncomfortable with it"

Landeyx: 10/10 "It's the best, accept it"

Voodoojazzoffire: 9/10- ''one of the best stocks''

Pretty Boy Pocket's Pistol

Overall score:4.9/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 6/10- ''Kinda like it, the survavility boost is very good''

Mr.Beasty: 4/10- ''Pretty boy's pocket pistol is not really good..''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 7/10- ''Good with Baby Face Blaster and if you hate fall damage''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 6/10

Biohazard_Ferrett: 8/10- ''Extra Health and insta-Birdscout''

Solly Sauce-5.2/10: "Unless you find yourself dying to fall damage or using Mr. Sandman, I find other Scout secondarys more reliable" (Other than stock pistol, and bonk)

Agent Walther: 1/10- "Was awesome to have one before, now it's just useless"

Landeyx: 0/10 "Gun mettle let die much good weapons,R.I.P. pretty boys"

Voodoojazzoffire: 7/10- ''a really good weapon if you hate falling damage, this gun may be usefull for your baby faces blaster so you dont die from fall damage, but that happens rarely... depending on the map you are in''

Winger

Overall score: 5.3/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 2/10- ''I almost never jumps I use the Baby Face Blaster 24/7, so I dont see a use for this weapon in my current playstyle''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 4/10- ''Good if you need a height advantage or are using the Baby Face Blaster''

Mr.Beasty: 6/10- ''This is good when you want to jump over something high...''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 1/10

Coffee: 7/10-''Much more of a utility than a weapon, but helps get to places you normally can't, or would have to use 2/3 jumps to get to.''

Landeyx: 10/10 "Extra far jumping is HANDY just equip it with the soda popper and the **** atomizer"

Voodoojazzoffire: 6/10- ''pistols arent my thing, but the increased jump height May be usefull in rare ocasions.''

IWantMyRevolver / Trade.tf : 7/10- ''I find uses for it.''

Flying Guillotine

Overall score: 6/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 2/10- ''I can NEVER aim one of this things''

Mr.Beasty: 1/10- ''never got a kill with this thing''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 5/10- ''Good with the sandman''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 6/10- ''Cause of sandman and guillotine combo''

Agent Walther: 10/10-"It's sad than i cannot give more than 10/10 to this. 1 hit equals to 4 mid range pistol hits, also it has my favourite thing in tf2 - bleeding ^^"

Landeyx: 10/10 "BLEEDING,CRITS WHEN BONKED"

Voodoojazzoffire: 8.5/10- ''just like it say, a guillotine, That is flying! combined with sandman, your a monster, when you fully charged them all up... and if you didnt miss them, its hard to use for begginers, get more practice on throwing this and the ball, then you will be almost unstoppable, as long as you never miss''

Crit a Cola

Overall score: 6.5/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 4/10- ''Gives you more damage, but makes a fragile class even more fragile.''

Mr.Beasty: 7/10- '' oh i love the crit a cola, gives you crits!''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 5/10- ''Good if you need kills.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 6/10

Landeyx: 10/10 "Nothing better then some crits"

Voodoojazzoffire: 7/10- ''a weapon, that is hard to know when or not to use it, as it is only usefull for ambushes,''

Bonk! Atomic Punch


Overall score: 7.4/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 7/10- ''SENTRYS AINT GOT ♥♥♥♥ ON ME''

Mr.Beasty: 6/10- ''MISS ME!''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 4/10- ''Good for distractions but not that usefull otherwise''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 9/10

Landeyx: 10/10 "Missed me!"

Voodoojazzoffire: 8.5/10 - ''praticly the best drink, in any situation need to pass by a couple of sentries? this drink is for you, only downside, if you equip this can of coke, you cannot use a pistol otherwise, for some reason,''

Pistol

Overall score: 7,4/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 4/10- ''Never fond a good use for it. I guess its good for taking out sentrys but that isnt Scout job.''

Mr.Beasty: 5/10- ''Not good..''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 10/10- ''Versatille and strong''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM- 9/10

Coffee: 9/10-''Use it all the time, and has great DMG up close if you can hit the shots.''

Landeyx: 8/10 "Some usefullness"

Voodoojazzoffire: 7/10- ''a very versatile weapon, this isnt my favorite gun, but il rate it a 7.''

Mad Milk

Overall score: 9,6/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 8/10- ''This non-milk-substance has saved my life countless times. And other's life too.''

Mr.Beasty: 10/10- ''This completes my life..''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin: 10/10- ''So good for health needs and being a teamplayer.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 10/10

Landeyx: 10/10 "Get HP on hit when milked in"

Voodoojazzoffire: 10/10- ''just... milk, best milk for my cerial''

Sun on a stick

Overall score: 2/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 1/10- ''Why does this weapon even exist?''

Mr.Beasty: 0/10- ''God Why..''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin 0/10- "If there are no pyros on your team this weapon is just useless ._."

Dave: 6/10 - ''Has it's moments, but otherwise... Nah.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 1/10

Spectre's Husbands:0/10-''If it could function like the Sharpened Volcano Fragment, then I would be glad to use this thing.''

Landeyx: 0/10 "No"

Voodoojazzoffire: 8/10- ''this weapon is pretty good, even though the less damage, but still that doesent matter much, and if you got flames uppon the enemy from a friendly pyro, this weapon is almost a nightmare im good at melee hitting, so i was able to kill 3 guys with this, even though they werent burning, includeing 2 scouts useing the "bat" ''

Wrap Assassin

Overall Score: 4,2/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 3/10 ''If I have to choose, I just choose the Sandman. And I cant never aim the balls anyway''

Mr.Beasty: 5/10 ''Someone might even bleed to death''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin 2/10 "This weapon needs a MAJOR buff like seriously it's so bad"

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 6/10

SDangel: 1/10- ''You should get ashamed if you get killed by this thing.

♥ Silver ♥ : 7.5/10-'' I always get into situations when the enemy chases directly after me, so it's funny when they don't realise I have it, I strike, and suddenly the tables turn.''

Agent Walther: 10/10- ''The most underrated melee weapon ever. Great if you like sandman and bleeding, but you want to use pistol and you don't use the melee to actually beat people with it.''

Landeyx: 2/10 "In combi with the guillotine you're very deadly,but we allready have bonk"

Voodoojazzoffire: 2/10- ''no... just, no.''

Bat

Overall score: 5.2/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 7/10- ''Nothing special, nothing bad, just stock...''

Mr.Beasty: 6/10-'' This thing is broken, it's not even working anymore''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 6/10

Landeyx: 0/10 "The first melee for scout you get in a drop you equip"

Voodoojazzoffire: 7/10 ''good ol' stock weapon, this weapon is good if you know how to be accurate with it, and if it doesent lag, like the other scouts, they miss a whole ton, that will get you killed instantly, learn how to not miss though, and you will be able to be a good melee scout''

Boston Basher

Overall Score: 5.4/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 4/10- ''I just kill myself with this thing.''

Mr.Beasty: 5/10- ''Use this and kill yourself..''

Jarl Balgruuf the 'Ballin 5/10-"Good if you need to build a übercharge fast in midst of a round but not that useful otherwise"

Dave: 9/10 - ''Devastating after 2 hits.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 3/10

Coffee: 9/10-''The next best, in my opinion. As a weapon, it's alright, but don't use it frequently. However, for utility, it's fantastic. It can help a Medic build uber, and it can (in dire situations) get you somewhere higher like the Atomizer.''

RamboTheMambo:8/10- ''Great for spy-checking.... Sometimes...''

Landeyx: 0/10 "Two hits and you're dead"

Voodoojazzoffire: 6/10- ''if you suck at scout melee accuracy, otherwise if you are very good at being accurate and hit people almost without missing with it, this weapon can be a 9/10''

Fan o' War

Overall score: 6,2/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 6/10 ''Only good with the Baby Face Blaster, otherwise, getting close, hitting him and then shooting him takes too long.''

Mr.Beasty: 4/10 ''Well not really good except if you want a challenge''

Dave: 7/10 - ''Great for being that annoying F2P Kid.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 9/10

Landeyx: 4/10 "Maybe"

Voodoojazzoffire: 7.5/10 ''this weapon can be a dangerous weapon to use, because being close to an enemy can be your doom, if you manage to hit them with it and escape, you praticly win, unless the enemy is a good killer, this weapon is good if your flanking''

TheMercWithoutAnUnusual: 6/10- ''It suffers the same thing as the Panic Attack... Except if it's MVM it's great''

Atomizer

Overall score:7,1/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 7/10- ''I used it 24/7 until I found the Candy Cane''

Mr.Beasty: 7/10- ''Not bad,Not good''

Dave: 3/10 - ''I'd rather not hit with it.''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 9/10

Coffee: 10/10-''Extraordinarily good. Helps dodge super well, and only for 10 HP per jump. 10 DMG to dodge is better than a 100 DMG pipe.''

Biohazard_Ferrett: 10/10- ''Instabirdscout the rage is priceless. Also very useful.''

Agent Walther:8,5/10- "Useful, maybe even priceless, but not my thing"

Landeyx: 1/10 "Combinated with winger and soda popper it has some usefullness but for the rest,No"

Voodoojazzoffire: 8.5/10- ''got to give it to them, a pretty good weapon... but im not a fan of it to much, so this is my rateing for this weapon''

Candy Cane

Overall score: 7.3/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 8/10- ''Every enemy is a potencial med kit... THATS AWESOME!'''

Mr.Beasty: 10/10- ''No need to eat chicken, when there's a candy cane around! Your enemy is food''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM: 6/10

Spectre's Husband:10/10-''I always wished to be the Majin Buu of Team Fortress 2.''

Coffee-1/10-''Yeah, it's good against incompetent teams. However, all I've seen it useful for is making my life much easier, as Scouts who use this die VERY easily to explosives.''

Landeyx: 10/10 "HP packs help you,your team and the enemy team"

Voodoojazzoffire: 6.5/10 im not a fan of this, because i alwase get a slight hope of survival when i get hit from rocket, and killing somebody with it drops some pills ((for bill)) there can be a bad side from it because enemy team can pick it up as well, so that can be a very bad thing, im not a whole fan of this melee weapon.

Frying Pan

Overall score: 8/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 10/10- ''NEED A DISPENSER HERE''

Mr.Beasty: 1/10- ''When you fight someone the sound is annoying when you hit.''

inhale my dong enragement child: 9/10-''i r8 8 m8 is gr8''

Dr. Moron:10/10-''If you wanna kill someone's ears (even more effective if they wear headphones) this is your scout melee.''

Landeyx: 10/10 "That sound :3"

Voodoojazzoffire: 8/10 ''FRYING PAN, loud as f*** if you want distractions, this weapon is the pan for you, if you want to go in silently, i suggest some other melee weapon and the "mythicial extra crits on hit" with this thing''

Sandman

Overall score: 8/10

The Crazed Buttstaber: 5/10 ''Just another thing that I cant aim...''

Mr.Beasty: 7/10 ''i can't even aim this, what is this even for!?''

TRYHARD HUNTER and co.TM:10/10

Reven: 10/10-''must giv soda pop and sandy 10/10''

Agent Walther: 5/10- "Not worth the -15 hp"

Landeyx: 11/10 "The 15 HP loss makes no difference, its the best weap in game."

Voodojazzoffire: 10/10 ''This bat, is pretty much, awsome, if you know how to use it very well, a very good combination with the flying guilotine.''

[DEV][GmT][RAF]Ouwhajah: 7/10- "OK if you're good at aiming, excellent combo with the F.G, kinda sucky for the -15HP, but still a good weapon.''

All voted and all done, its time to see what the community thinks the best loadout is (acccording to the given scores):

Best Loadout

Stock Scattergun
Mad Milk
Atomizer

The Stock scattergun offers nothing bad, but also nothing good. Now that can be complimented with the atomizer, which gives extra mobility for a cost of 15 health. But if you ever found yourself doing to much triple jumps, you got the mad milk to help you, since it can regenerate health pretty well.

And just for those times you want a challenge, or lolz:

Worst Loadout

Shortstop
Winger
Sun on a stick

Shortstop and Winger use the same ammo. The Winger can do extra damage, true, but youre going to spend all your clips for the shortop if you want to use that extra damage. And the sun on a stick is just terrible.

Welp, you saw some examples, you saw some weapons. Now go into the comments and start giving your opinion on weapons. If this get a little popular, Ill make a sequel... maybe...

Spookylicious profile: http://steamproxy.net/profiles/76561198063625194/

SAVE THE MELON!

http://steamproxy.net/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=534962793